Pietta 1858 New Model Army Sheriff .44 Percussion Revolver, 5.5 in Octagonal Barrel, Bright Silver Finish
This F.lli Pietta 1858 New Model Army Sheriff is a .44 percussion reproduction with a compact 5.5 in barrel and a Remington-pattern solid topstrap frame. It features a bright silver steel finish, an unfluted six-chamber cylinder, and checkered walnut grips with diamond-shaped escutcheons. Italian proof house markings confirm its origin and black-powder proof.
Condition
Overall Condition: Good condition, showing some signs of prior use and handling.
Bore Condition: Excellent - Clean, mirror finish, no signs of wear.
Bore Rifling: Excellent Rifling - Sharp lands and grooves.
Specific Condition Notes: This firearm is in solid shape with cosmetic imperfections, including scratches, blemishes, and areas of finish loss.
What’s Included
- No case included
The Sheriff configuration uses a 5.5 in octagonal steel barrel that shortens overall length and shifts the balance for a handier feel while maintaining the .44 percussion chambering. The unfluted six-shot cylinder and single-action percussion system follow the traditional Remington pattern.
A solid topstrap frame provides the classic Remington profile in steel with a bright silver finish across the frame, cylinder, and receiver. A brass trigger guard offers a period-correct accent. The checkered walnut grips with diamond-shaped escutcheons give a secure hold and refined look.
Sights are fixed with a topstrap rear notch and a fixed front sight. The 1:30 twist and well-defined rifling in the octagonal barrel support consistent round-ball stabilization. The bore is clean and bright.
Made in Italy by F.lli Pietta, this reproduction carries Italian proof house stamps, including PN black-powder and Gardone marks. It retains the Remington-style, solid-frame architecture and bright silver-colored steel finish throughout.

